Why The Latest Minnesota Vikings Quarterback Signing Is So Intriguing

This morning, the Minnesota Vikings announced they were signing quarterback Carson Wentz, bringing him back for his second season with the team.

The team announced Wentz had agreed to terms on a one-year deal to keep him on the roster, which recently added Kyler Murray and already contains J.J. McCarthy and Max Brosmer.

There was a bit of a storybook element to Wentz joining Minnesota last season, having grown up in neighboring North Dakota. The "(almost) one of us" storyline was intriguing as he ended up being needed in relief of an injured (or "injured" if you believe what some people say) J.J. McCarthy in the heart of last season.

Wentz played 5 games last year, going 2-3 during a stretch of games where he looked decent at times as he threw for 1,216 yards and 6 touchdowns (and 5 interceptions).

READ MORE: Kyler Murray Reveals He's "Cried Real Tears" Over Vikings As A Long-Time Fan Of Minnesota

The biggest thing that derailed him was a shoulder injury that impacted his game play for a few games and had him looking miserable by the end of his stint last season, before getting the hook to have surgery on his injured shoulder.

By bringing back Wentz, the Vikings now have three top 10 first-round NFL Draft picks in their quarterback room - and undrafted Max Brosmer. This signing makes some feel like the Vikings either move on from Brosmer or maybe send him to the practice squad.

Wentz was drafted second overall in 2016, Murray was taken first overall in 2019, and McCarthy was taken at 10th overall in 2024.

So, what makes signing Carson Wentz so interesting?

Some experts are looking at the quarterback room, wondering what the hierarchy of the position is going to be. In most cases, teams have their starter (the most expensive of the bunch), a veteran backup, and a young, inexpensive emergency fill-in or project player.

Looking at Minnesota's quarterback position through that lens, who is who?

The short answer is, that clearly isn't the current formula the Vikings are following.

Some people are suggesting this move to bring in Wentz spells the end to the J.J. McCarthy era in Minnesota, with the working theory that Kyler Murray is the presumed starter, Wentz is the backup to Kyler, and then the team either retains Brosmer or finds a new third-stringer. This is all, as they argue, because the team wouldn't retain McCarthy as a third-string quarterback, and they could try to trade him away.

The quarterback situation in Minnesota is abnormally cheap and abnormally even in terms of how you might rate a depth chart.

Kyler is here on a league-minimum veteran deal, McCarthy is on a rookie contract, and while the details of the Wentz deal haven't been shared yet, it is assumed they are similar to his inexpensive 2025 contract. This means they aren't overly obligated financially to any of their quarterbacks.

Get our free mobile app

All of this leads to what could be a legitimate three-way competition for the role of starting quarterback for the Minnesota Vikings in 2026. It is quite possible that the team makes its assessment through the offseason, camp, and preseason, and could potentially move on from whoever the lowest performer is, trading them away or cutting them, depending on who it is and what the situation ends up being.

No matter who the starter ends up being, they'll have a pretty good team around them. Even with the quarterback carousel the Vikings had last year - with some putrid performances along the way - the team still managed a record over .500.

Most of that team is returning again this season, and defensive guru Brian Flores is sticking around to keep cooking on his mad scientist defense that kept the team in games last year.

As a Vikings fan, I have a fear that this could all shape up to be a disaster, but it also has the chance to be good. Maybe Kyler is a great starter for the Vikings. Perhaps J.J. figured things out. Possibly a healthy Wentz re-captures some of his early-career magic.

Or...the team chooses the wrong starter, they deal away the wrong guy who goes on to have a great season for another team, and the 2026 season ends just as frustrating as last year's. Here's hoping that doesn't happen, but after being a Vikings fan as long as I have, I've been conditioned to consider these possibilities.

No matter what, it seems like we won't really know for sure who the starting quarterback is going to be until the end of the summer. It'll make for some interesting storylines to follow for quite some time.

TBD on whether it is a "good" kind of interesting or "bad" kind of interesting.